The Boy in the Striped Pajamas Plugged in Movie Review
All things truly wicked start from an innocence-Ernest Hemingway
I was so excited my theater got The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, from the moment I saw this trailer, I knew I was in for a treat. This movie only looked incredible, even though it's a touchy subject field with the holocaust, it still looked similar information technology was going to be a great story. Anybody always makes a annotate near the innocence of childhood, what it was like to just not accept reason, to simply become with the flow of things before adults tell you what you lot take to practise. So I watched The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas today and this movie seriously is one of the saddest films I have ever seen, merely I felt information technology was very maturely handled. The actors are swell and the story is very touching, to watch these two boys from two completely different worlds who come together just to have fun, exist boys, not because of the deviation of their groundwork.
Set during World War II, a story seen through the innocent eyes of Bruno, the eight-year-old son of the commandant at a concentration camp, whose forbidden friendship with a Jewish boy on the other side of the camp argue. The boys have a dandy friendship talking every day, enjoying the visitor. But when the male parent gives Bruno a Nazi propaganda loving tutor, Bruno becomes confused, is his father an evil man or is his friend the evil one? Honey his country and practice his duty or don't judge and just stay true to his friend? Bruno must decide all this with some scary consequences ahead of him.
The Male child in the Striped Pyjamas is a fantastic motion picture, though if you run across it, I practice recommend bringing the tissues. I couldn't believe the chemistry they had with these two young actors, they worked so well together as these innocent boys who both have no idea what's going on. Bruno doesn't know why his friend is behind fences, and his friend doesn't know why he's there either. The catastrophe is extremely powerful and the story keeps yous interested. I practice recommend seeing The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, information technology's a treasure from 2008.
ix/x
217 out of 252 institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bruno And Shmuel
I can't speak for other people, simply for me The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas is a film that can be seen once and once merely because the impact is so shattering. Non even a stone statue can exist not moved by this film, this child's eye view of the Holocaust.
Bruno is an 8 year erstwhile German child whose father David Thewlis is an officer in the Wehrmacht. They're living a nice life in the beginning of World State of war Ii in metropolitan Berlin. Thewlis gets orders even so aircraft him to a command in a prissy rural area of southern Germany, presumably Bavaria. Similar any other kid he'south upset at being confused from his friends and his schoolhouse, but he certainly hasn't much to say in the matter.
So the family is uprooted to a lovely pastoral expanse where Dad's been put in charge of a concentration camp. Not one of the bigger ones like Auschwitz and Dachau, but a small one that his superiors expect Thewlis to run efficiently.
Young Bruno has absolutely no one to play with and he wanders over to the camp. His parents feel he'south way too young to understand about these things and he makes friends with a kid on the other side of the spinous wire, a young Jewish male child named Shmuel who wears those funny striped pyjamas like anybody else in the camp.
Two things struck me nigh The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas. When I did a review of The Diary Of Anne Frank, the biggest impression I got out of the film was the ordinariness of that small group of Jews hidden in that attic. Who could possibly think these people were whatsoever kind of threat to civilization but for being and assertive in their religion? We get to see the other side of the looking glass hither, a view of this very average German family, as well young Bruno and Thewlis, there'southward female parent Vera Famiga and daughter Amber Beattie. Famiga is not happy ane flake with her domestic state of affairs and it's slowly dawning on her that the politics and policies of the Tertiary Reich is the root of her concerns. As for Beattie, she'southward actually buying into the whole Nazi affair, partly because she's going through puberty and a young and handsome adjutant to her father played by Rupert Friend is stirring up those first womanly feelings.
Just to all intents and purposes this is your average German family, not also much different than the Frank family in that attic, but that this regime of hate has fabricated Thewlis a decease merchant.
The second thing that struck me and it'due south what gives hope to this crazy world is what passes between Asa Butterfield as Bruno and Jack Scanlon as Shmuel. If all we are as humans are reflections of our parents prejudices there would exist absolutely no hope for mankind. Just we practice abound, we do question, some of u.s.a. just don't accept everything that'south fed to the states. Nosotros don't run into Shmuel's globe of the camp until the very end, the boys more often than not have contact with a barbed wire fence between them. Simply we encounter Bruno and his sister being now home schooled in Nazi teachings and his innocent contact with that kid on the other side of the fence makes him question what'due south going on.
The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas is ane of the best films of 2008. You will non forget the performances of Butterfield and Scanlon and the developed cast members. The end will shatter your listen, just the film'southward depiction of friendship growing in the worst possible circumstances is also a message of hope.
28 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
"We're meant to be enemies. Did you know that"?
Warning: Spoilers
This was truly one of the near disturbing movies I've ever seen. I can't imagine the friendship story having any semblance of historical fact to it, merely it makes i think almost the randomness of existence and how tenuous it can be to be on the 'wrong' side. The grapheme of Bruno (Asa Butterfield) is the image of childlike innocence, and his view of the world is ane of total acceptance to a young mind incapable of inhumanity and horror. The motion-picture show skillfully contrasts his character with that of sister Gretel (Amber Beattie), somewhat older and already under the influence of Hitler Youth propaganda. The conflicted portrayal of the female parent Elsa (Vera Farmiqa) is also set against the subdued brutality of the Commandant father (David Thewliss).
With a title similar "The Boy in the Striped Pajamas", I really didn't know what to expect, and even well into the picture I didn't have any idea how the story would be brought to a conclusion. When it finally became apparent how this was going to end, it was all I could exercise to steel myself for the unthinkable and the unconscionable.
It's a constant source of confusion to my heed how this world tin can contain such disparate elements leading to heroic examples of humanity contrasted against unspeakable acts of horror and depravity. By whatsoever measure of skillful fortune, maybe a moving-picture show like this can convince even a single person with hate and prejudice in their eye that it's a random whim of the universe that any single person is born the way they are.
vii out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Stunning! Simply Stunning!!!
There have been more a few films on the subject field of the Holocaust, possibly the daddy of them all being Steven Spielberg's "Schindler'due south List" based on the book "Schindler'south Ark" by Thomas Keneally. Much ameliorate, withal, in my mind is Costa-Gavras' "Amen" based on Rolf Hochhuth's play "Le Vicaire". Now Mark Herman'south "The Boy in the Striped Pajamas", itself based on John Boyne's novel, is fit to mentioned alongside these two great films.
I was initially doubtful at the premise of this flick since my knowledge of Holocaust history suggested that 8 year onetime boys would accept been sent straight to the gas chambers on arrival rather than set to work in a camp (obviously I am happy to be fix directly on this betoken if I am wrong). And having seen the motion picture, I also dubiousness that the boy in the campsite (Shmuel, well played by Jack Scanlon) would be able to sit down at the camp fence undetected long enough to meet and talk to Bruno, the military camp Commandant's son (an astonishingly assured performance by newcomer Asa Butterfield).
At that place has also been some criticism of the fact that all the actors speak in Received Pronounciation English accents (fifty-fifty American actress Vera Farmiga, whose English language accent is completely faultless). This is true, although to be completely accurate, all the actors would have to speak in German and the film would take had to exist subtitled equally a result.
In truth, notwithstanding, none of these criticisms actually matters a damn. For even though all of the to a higher place is undeniably true, the picture still works. And my, how information technology works. When it finished, I sabbatum in my seat stunned (I had the aforementioned reaction after watching "Disaster Film" last week, but most definitely non for the same reason, I assure yous).
The Holocaust equally seen through the prism of 8 twelvemonth quondam German male child is a novel approach and although nosotros all know what is happening at the camp nearby, at the beginning, he does not. And every step he takes, he gets closer to discovering the truth, losing his childhood innocence in the procedure.
What I liked about this film is the sophisticated and multi-layered portrayal of the High german characters. None of them are one dimensional wholly evil characters simply nor are they wholly practiced either (not even Bruno who tells lies on several occasions, one occasion which results in brutal punishment for i of the prisoners as a effect).
With good performances from Asa Butterfield as Bruno, Amber Beattie equally his sister, David Thewlis as his father, Vera Farmiga as his mother and Jack Scanlon as Shmuel, this may not exist the outset film about the loss of childhood innocence in the Holocaust (Roberto Benigni beat Herman to information technology with "Life is Beautiful" and whilst Benigni's film has a powerful terminate of its own, fifty-fifty that does not compare to the powerful shattering ending which this film possesses) but it is the all-time and most effective to engagement.
With restrained management by Marker Herman and a similarly restrained score from James Horner, if this film does non win the lid total of Oscars adjacent year that it surely deserves, the Academy of Motility Picture Arts and Sciences will have shown itself to be completely irrelevant.
227 out of 291 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A very good film
When my son (nearly 12 years erstwhile) read the book he was awake until 5am that dark thinking nearly the story and what it all meant; he had some penetrating questions besides. A twenty-four hours or so later he said that he thought that it would make a practiced film, and imagine his please when he saw that in that location was a flick of the book.
I accept taken him to see the movie; and was riveted. I think that the style of the film is really that of an sometime fashioned family movie, withal the subject matter is emotionally very demanding and all the meliorate for that. It does what good drama should do - makes you think and experience. As the credits ran, at the showing that I saw, no one moved or spoke for a minute or two. The Holocaust is a difficult discipline, but to tell a story in such a way that it is attainable to a 12 yr is a great achievement.
There have been some comments that the bandage speak English (rather than, presumably, High german) and that this is somehow a bad thing. What are the alternatives? Either sub-titles or daft 'ello 'ello accents. In some ways the ordinariness of the Nazis and the family points up the horror of what happened – that ordinary people can do the worst of things to fellow human beings.
255 out of 313 institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Stunning
I read the volume "The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas" later on coming across it in the library almost a year ago, and it amazed me. The unique approach taken by Mr Boyne put the subject matter across in a fresh and, if information technology is possible, even more center-wrenching fashion. When I heard they were making the volume into a motion-picture show, I was very anxious, as I thought that they couldn't possibly convey the book onto the screen appropriately.
I am delighted to say that I was entirely wrong. I have just this minute returned home from seeing the film and I am absolutely stunned. The pic is practically identical to the book, which was wonderful to see, and I thought that the acting was superb. Vera Farmiga and Asa Butterfield were, I thought, exceptional. The flick was handled fantastically and I believe that the feel of the novel was non lost in the translation to screen.
Seeing the flick was a lot more intense than reading the volume and, fifty-fifty knowing what was coming, I plant myself sobbing at the terminate, as were my father and stride-female parent, the latter of whom had never read the book, and was utterly shocked. This is the showtime film I take ever seen in which the whole audition were silent from beginning to end, and and then, when the film ended, not a single person moved for a long time afterwards.
The film is an incredibly powerful, moving story, told superbly well by a stellar bandage and crew. I would recommend it immensely to everyone.
200 out of 244 institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Holocaust Presented as a Grim Children'southward Fable
Alarm: Spoilers
Information technology'due south official. The award now goes to the British for making the most depressing pic I have always seen. For the offset time in my moving-picture show-going life I witnessed an audience member's physical reaction to a film when a begetter was observed outside the screening room for "The Boy in the Striped Pajamas" collapsed confronting the wall with his child emotionally distraught and crying in his lap. With the rest of the audience, including myself, stunned into silence after the film and exiting the theater a communal internalized wreck, I don't know if I was more than devastated by what I had witnessed on screen or by that poor trivial child out in the hallway whose father for some reason thought this pic would provide a history lesson his child could stomach at such a immature historic period. As the film proves, the innocent are not cut out for war.
That being said, I would recommend "The Male child in the Striped Pajamas" to anyone emotionally prepared to sit through it. The moving picture's climax will hit you like a sucker dial to the gut…simply in that location is a lesson to be learned for those in the right frame of mind and mature enough to handle information technology. In adapting John Boyne's novel, director Mark Herman envisions the Holocaust equally a grim kid's fable, and in doing so, presents the historical events from a daringly simple new angle. Yeah, "Life is Beautiful" attempted something similar not so long ago, simply that film was told from the indicate of view of a child-like human being trying to shield his son from horrors and had precipitous tonal shifts that sank its dramatic bear upon. "The Boy in the Striped Pajamas", however, keeps a powerfully consistent tone, and until the harrowing final act, is entirely told from the point-of-view of the young son of a German commandant assigned to run a concentration camp.
Herman directs the film adequately well, utilizing visual motifs and not so subtle foreshadowing (that left me with a sinking feeling in my gut as the film progressed), and he is aided profoundly by the wonderful cinematography by Benoit Delhomme. The script, though contrived in parts, is tight and moves at a brisk pace, and the commonly sappy composer James Horner shows not bad restraint with his score that is both haunting and reverent to the events that unfold. The more often than not British cast is stunning. As little Bruno, Asa Butterfield successfully permits united states of america to relate to the child's naïve innocence without ever allowing the graphic symbol to get cloying or blissfully ignorant. David Thewlis commands attention as his tortured and misguided father, and Vera Farmiga is dynamite as his distressed mother. She gives a powerhouse performance and proves yet over again to be a gripping chameleon of an actress nearing the level of a Cate Blanchett.
With its slim run-time, "The Boy in the Striped Pajamas" seems a sound option for a future generation of teachers to show their high school students in lieu of an epic like "Schindler's List". It also makes a good visual companion slice to Eli Wiesel's literary "Night" every bit information technology shows a fictionalized flip-side to the same tragedy. As the existent survivor accounts sadly fade with the passing of time, the horrors of the Holocaust volition remain firmly in place in the world's historical fiction for centuries to come long later the final person who really witnessed it has died. These stories will forever be screaming at us, and we would exist wise to listen. Fault the motion picture if you wish, but in its assuming child-like simplicity information technology shows the insidious evil of the Nazis as two-fold. Yeah, they slaughtered six-million innocent Jews, but it was an act of murder-suicide as in doing then they too sentenced themselves to death.
34 out of 48 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Perfectly weighted pic...
I'm a homo's man, and it takes something really exceptional to interruption my emotionless machine persona. This moving picture ripped me apart and reminded me (and my partner) of humanity inside even the most hardened man.
Perfectly weighted picture in every style, from pace to acting and all framed with a wonderful score. The subtlety of the looks passing between the actors and a finale that ensured silence until the final credit rolled, makes this one of the all-time films i've seen in a long time.
This is the offset review I take never written and i cannot think of a better way to have opened my account.
434 out of 533 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The power of a child's innocence
Alarm: Spoilers
Being Jewish and having family that died in the holocaust, these types of movies always touch a nerve with me.
I thought it was a fantastic thought having a movie based effectually the war through a naive child'south eyes. What this picture show showed to me was how when you remove the political, racial and cultural issues from people at that place is potential for us all to become along.
The principal graphic symbol played the office of 'innocence' beautifully and his non judgemental eyes merely made my heart flutter at the thought that during such barbaric times compassion withal lived within humans.
The film maintained fascination throughout, seeing how the effects of what were going on around him effected the balance of his family unit, which led to the finale. For me it showed the ultimate idea of 'shoe on the other foot'... how in life we can feel OK about handing it out but when taking it back we realise what kind of twisted evil beings ane can exist.
I highly recommend this movie for whatsoever adult, though this film is based around Nazi Germany and the Jews, the ideas behind it can apply to any subversive situation that is going on in the globe today.
Overall this is a 10/10, powerful stuff.
Andrew Barbarash
52 out of 68 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Amazing
Although it starts of slow,you shortly get wrapped up in the story and feel as if you are in that location. It'south amazing to come across the different points of view and the acting is so conceivable you lot feel as if it is all happening there and and so. I accept cried at films in the cinema before but this is the only moving-picture show that has made me want to sob. When it finished and the credits started rolling, no one moved from their seats or said anything. We were all shocked, and when people did outset to go upwards an exit the picture palace, still no one said anything. It is the best film i have ever seen and recommend everyone sees information technology.
Sophie x 10 10
158 out of 210 plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
One of the nearly affecting pieces of Cinema released in years
In that location are more dramatic and more than philosophical pieces of movie theater dealing with this very emotive subject, only few deal with the horror, futility and falsehood of the "final solution" with such clear simplicity. Nosotros see the lead characters every bit both humans and monsters we see internal disharmonize and how they each come up to terms with their conflicts, higher up all we see how futile their conclusions were.
There will be the anticipated comparisons with Schindler's Listing but you might also desire to compare this picture show to "The Counterfeiters" which also deals with the conflicts necessary to survive. Watching this motion-picture show I kept existence drawn back to Primo Levi's book "If This is Man" the story of his time equally a prisoner suffering from this evil.
The great success of the pic is its simplicity, it does not seek to over analyse just simply allows the development of the characters to tell the story.
One of the contributers spoke of how he was in screen ix (if I call back correctly) in Cineworld Dublin - I was in Screen eleven and I can had the same experience, the moving-picture show ended and no i moved, all were in a land of stupor, no, sorrow. This is not a picture show for young children, but older children and adults familiar with the evil addressed in this moving picture should go and see it. This movie deserves keen success. I charge per unit information technology 9 out of 10 and would have given it a perfect score except for some modest technical questions, but none that take away from this fantastic slice of cinema - All associated with this movie should be rightly proud of at that place work and if any of you read these comments - Thank You!
148 out of 192 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Utterly Devastating
My fiancé and I purchased tickets for a special advanced screening of this flick during the Carnegie Film Festival in Dunfermline, Fife. I didn't realise, but we were i of the first people to meet it. I volition try and not spoil it and continue the review very unproblematic and straight forward.
The film is mainly shot through the eyes of Bruno played by Asa Butterfield growing upwards in state of war time Deutschland during the holocaust. Subsequently relocating at the will of the German Army, the motion picture then centres on the friendship between Bruno and Shmuel (Jack Scanlon). I will end information technology there equally I don't wish to spoil the residuum of the film.
Putting to i side the fact that anybody has a flawless English accent (which does brand it difficult to hate them at kickoff), the cinematics, sound, editing and to a higher place all acting are a credit to the British film industry.
Asa Butterfield is fine young actor and I'grand sure will be destined for even greater things in the future.
Equally I mentioned to a higher place, I won't give anything away, only I will say that this is the first time I have been to the Cinema and anybody sabbatum placidity right up until the stop of the credits.
Delight, please run across this moving-picture show. It will remain with yous for a long time.
315 out of 424 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A motion picture that everyone must watch
I was sitting at the very back row of Cineworld, Dublin screen nine and struggling with my tears. I thought information technology would be extremely embarrassing if people see tears in my optics. But I was and so wrong! The lady sitting beside me was crying similar anything. Finally nosotros ended upwards with the move and it started showing casts on its black screen. But, not a single person moved from his seat or probably lost their (including myself) power to move. The simply sound I heard was the sound of people'south emotion. Guy sitting one row before me hugged his girlfriend who were crying like a footling kid. The guy himself was also in tear. I saw a daughter from Cineworld cleaning staff with horrifying red eyes. Everyone was spellbound in that location!
I am talking about the moving-picture show THE Boy IN THE STRIPED PYJAMAS, unexpectedly a likewise good film. I didn't take a unmarried clue most the movie itself and just tried to explore something new. Fortunately or unfortunately, Bruno (main cast of the movie), a young 8-years former kid who love to explore new world explored also much for us that made us all weep while leaving the movie house. I just don't desire to spoil your entertainment by giving hints about the story. Rather, I would propose yous to watch the movie and discover some critical facts that sometime we forget in this heartless world.
THE BOY IN THE STRIPED PYJAMAS, a moving-picture show from an Irish author and an English director; everyone must watch. If you tell me to rate, I would say, i to 10 scale is not enough to rate this movie. We better proceed it above rating!
183 out of 257 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
it's directed fine and there's some good acting, merely it's also dim and silly and contrived
Warning: Spoilers
The Boy in Striped Pajamas, aside from it looking more often than not like a slightly upgraded Television set movie (it's financed by BBC) and featuring British and non-British actors not changing any of their accents for their characters, is likewise likewise obvious for its own expert. Holocaust = bad is the bones message of the picture, and a message that evidently never sinks into the head of Bruno, the 8 twelvemonth erstwhile boy who befriends Shmool, the boy of the title who befriends him across the fence of the concentration campsite. Information technology as well seems to be a movie pitched at children more than adults, which would be fine except that information technology'south not fifty-fifty a very skillful children's movie, unless they don't know much at all about the holocaust- which, perhaps is likely. Peradventure my standards are too high afterward so many endless films regarding Nazis and the holocaust, just among the many of them (Schindler's List by far the masterpiece and others like Jakob the Liar remake worse), this ane is just... meh.
Does it provide a wait at how innocence had fiddling place of the Nazi'southward plans against the Jewish people? Yep. Does it have a signal regarding expert versus evil? Possibly. It's scope is mainly centered on Bruno's experiences around the family house where his begetter (barely ane-dimensional David Thewlis) is the Nazi soldier and his mother (Vera Farmiga, almost 2-dimensional but non quite) who is horrified by what she finds out goes on at the camps. And, as well, about the kindness of some people who could not comprehend (or simply weren't up on the facts or too immature, similar Bruno) the evil possible with the Nazis. All of these ideas and perspectives are fine. It's the execution of these on film, in drama, that counts, and the performances and the management just don't add up.
On top of this are some contrivances to the plot that keep things a little too thick for comfort. Maybe I only wasn't as emotionally invested in the ending every bit some other critics have been, but it starts as being pretty stupid - for Bruno to merely casually dig his way into the campsite and so slip on the military camp wearing apparel without anyone noticing is one thing - so, the final straw, with the big lesson being delivered as a manipulative sucker dial to the parents as Bruno and Shmool are shuffled off to the gas bedchamber at but the verbal moment they go into the i bunker. This is just a cruel twist, something done to drive tragedy into a story that doesn't provide much except for a feeling of "... what?" If information technology touches other people who don't see any of the obvious lines drawn in Herman's script or direction, proficient for them. For me, it'south a total emotional sham.
21 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
One of the nearly of import (and emotionally devastating) war movies of all time.
The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas is an incredibly devastating motion picture which will leave you equally an emotional wreck past the end... trust me. Even and then, information technology is one of the sides of the war which is rarely shown in picture palace and as a outcome, is a very of import view and should be watched past anybody. I originally watched this movie in Secondary School when i was no older than 13 (my English teacher must savour watching kids cry). It has stuck with me ever since, and still to this solar day it leaves me speechless.
The story is told from the perspective of 8 year old Bruno, which provides the audience with a different perspective to the war that isn't seen too often. From an innocent mind. This merely helps to make the movie's catastrophe so much more than powerful. Without giving anything abroad, this picture will stick with you for a long time.
The movie itself has been created beautifully. The cinematics, sound and editing is amazing and really helps create the perfect moving-picture show. I desire to mention separately how good the actors were though. Some of these scenes wouldn't have been anywhere well-nigh as constructive if information technology wasn't for the acting. ten/10. Makes me so proud of the British film industry :')
I highly suggest you spotter this movie. Simply have some tissues ready.
x out of 12 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Accept the Idea and Run
While I thought this was a good movie, my thoughts at times came back to the standard premise effectually the state of affairs comedy. Let's take this character and this character, throw them together, and run across what happens. There are so many movies almost the Holocaust. Some are based on existent events and others take the events that took place and extrapolate on them. I couldn't become over the premise of "What if yous took the young son of the commandant of a expiry camp during the Holocaust and he met a little Jewish boy?" The whole relationship and the lack of basic security kind of throws me. The boys seem to take the run of things. When they meet, except for the siren that forces one of them back, it's as if they are ignored. Now, if we accept the premise put forth and tin believe in information technology, information technology becomes, of course, an indictment of bullheaded loyalty and a tragedy. I just never got in that location. The performances are good and there'southward that edge that Nazi ability presents, so it's still very difficult to watch, only I'thou but left with an empty, skeptical sense.
5 out of 7 plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Stirring and highly acclaimed riveting drama about a High german boy who has intense relationship with a Jew in striped pyjamas is powered past splendid performances
The picture show begins on the tranquillity introspective look at young Bruno ( Butterfield )who lives happily with his family, a sugariness mother (Vera Farmiga, elder sis and begetter (David Thewlis), a stiff Nazi commandant. The begetter is promoted as prison commandant and the family is relocated at a mansion nearly a concentration campsite. There Bruno befriends another small boy named Shmuel( Scanlon) , rarely dressed in striped pyjama and backside an barbed wire. The moving-picture show is well paced nether betoken of view of an innocent boy.
This haunting modern tragedy is an artful, immaculately performed and resonant drama developing harrowing events. Interesting film is sometimes slipping into banal sentimentality or outright melodrama, two things that in this powerful portrayal are well combined. Brooding picture full of fine character studio , but over-all this is an engaging look to infancy friendship with periods of heavy-handed sentimentality. The first part on the movie focuses on the honey male parent, son and wife but after that, sally the differences . The 2d one-half shifts to the friendship amongst them, a High german and Jewish boy who lives behind an electric argue. The documentary film the Nazis set to deceive Allied is based on real event, in fact 'Theresienstadt', the Czechoslovack ghetto metropolis used by the Gestapo to persuade the outside world of their humane treatment of the Jews. Packs a chilling observation of the ¨banality of evil¨, including Nazi officers dealing with the best utilization of crematoriums. The atrocities are depicted matter of factly every bit by-products of sheer Nazi evil. Exciting and excruciating last scenes into the gas chambers with utilise of Zyclon B toxicant. Excellent acting from adult actors every bit children players. Astonishing and commanding acting from two small boys equally Butterfly and Scanlon. Vera Farmiga gives the functioning of his career every bit understated and affecting female parent. David Thewlis is watchable, convincing and versatile . Proficient secondary cast as Richard Johnson and Sheila Hancock as the grandfathers, furthermore David Hayman every bit Jew servant and Rupert Friend as cruel Nazy lieutenant.
From the best-selling novel by John Boyne which the same director adapted the play and realized this magnificent picture. Due to the sensitive nature of story information technology contains sensible musical score by the master James Horner. Colorful and atmospheric cinematography by Benoit Delhomme. A tour De forcefulness and labor of dear for filmmaker and screenwriter, Mark Herman (little voice, Brassed off, Blame it on the bellboy) , who finally garnered the respect and attention every bit good director he deserves. Other important films treating the Holocaust and concentration camps are the following : Holocaust (Marvin J. Chomsky), Triumph of the spirit(Robert 1000. Young), Sophie's choice (Alan J. Pakula), Schindler's list (Spielberg), Life is cute(Roberto Benigni), The grayness zone (Tim Blake Nelson), and several others.
9 out of fifteen found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Heartbreaking Sight of State of war and Holocaust through Innocent Eyes
In World State of war Two, in Berlin, Commander Ralph (David Thewlis) is promoted and assigned to be in charge of a "labor piece of work" in the countryside. After a farewell party, he moves with his wife (Vera Farmiga), his twelve twelvemonth-one-time daughter Gretel (Amber Beattie), his viii year-old son Bruno (Asa Butterfield) and their maid to a huge house nearby the concentration camp that Bruno believes it is a strange subcontract with the locals wearing pyjamas all twenty-four hour period long. The lonely Bruno feels bored without his friends at home and decides to explore the area without the cognition of his family. He goes to the "subcontract" and befriends the prisoner Shmuel (Jack Scanlon), who is besides 8 years old, and they encounter each other everyday but separated though an electrified barbwire fence. Bruno lives a conflict about the Jews while having classes with his tutor and at home with the High german officers; when Shmuel'south begetter disappears in the camp, Bruno digs a hole and wears pyjamas to help his friend to notice his father with tragic consequences.
Yesterday I watched the heartbreaking "The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas" and I am however moved with this touching and tragic tale of ii pure boys and their sight of state of war and holocaust through their innocent eyes. The performances are top-notch, highlighting the expressive Asa Butterfield in the lead office and Jack Scanlon; inclusive I intend to see "Son of Rambow" very before long considering Asa Butterfield works also in this moving picture. The unusual approach of the holocaust is original since it is seen and felt by a immature German boy and his naive female parent, and the reaction of his female parent when she discovers what the smoke is indeed is impressive. The sets, decoration and costumes are also magnificent. The very sad conclusion recalled me "Hair", when the lead grapheme is in the wrong place in the wrong time and I doubt a viewer tin can see information technology without feeling whatever emotion or even crying. Final but not the least, "The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas" is never corny or manipulative, and I have just included this film in my list of favorite. My vote is 9.
Title (Brazil): "O Garoto exercise Pijama Listrado" ("The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas")
12 out of 22 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A World War 2-movie for housewives
"The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas" is a romanticized version of a fourth dimension in history that had nothing romantic about information technology. The title itself is an indication that this motion picture is going to depict the horrors of World War Two through the innocent eyes of a lilliputian male child, an approach that I already despised in the similarly out of place "Life Is Beautiful". Personally, I don't believe in the natural goodness of children or in their naive innocence when it comes to befriending others, but that'due south not fifty-fifty the main problem I accept with this movie.
From the beginning, "The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas" is only looking for means to dramatize the story. The principal characters are a family that consists of two children, a high-ranking Nazi-father, an plain quixotic female parent and a rebellious grandmother that questions Hitler's party in public. Sounds pretty realistic, right? I bet there were hundreds of families like this in Nazi Federal republic of germany.
Anyway, when Nazi Dad gets a promotion the family unit is forced to movement to Auschwitz, where they live just a few minutes away from the infamous concentration camp. Now, this is where we learn a couple of things about the family. At the age of eight and 12 respectively, the kids patently accept never really been in contact with any kind of Nazi Propaghanda at all. Only at present are they existence told about "The Jew" and the "nifty ethnic cleansing" by a private tutor. Wouldn't you lot think that the children of a high ranking Nazi would have been brainwashed from the day they were built-in? What'southward even more unbelievable is that their mother apparently didn't know or intendance what her husband'due south beliefs where, either. But at present she starts to find out about what'southward being done to the Jews and, of course, she totally opposes to it. Of course! She's only been married to this guy for years. The man probably has lots of lovable graphic symbol traits that totally overshadow the conformist, sadistic, mass murdering side of his personality.
Anyway, the family unit starts their life in Auschwitz and the son Bruno starts exploring the area. He soon gets to the concentration camp and strikes up a friendship with Shmuel, a little boy who is imprisoned there. Shmuel but happens to sit around at the argue most days relaxing. Obviously concentration camp was bit similar a schoolyard, where anybody could just move freely without ever getting mobbed by guards or anything (actually, past that description schoolyard was fifty-fifty tougher).
And so, that's pretty much the situation from which the whole drama arises. Information technology's a totally synthetic and unbelievable gear up upwards, a motion picture fabricated to appeal to the Rosamunde Pilcher-loving housewife. The stage design, the kitschy cinematography and the score all add up to a Hollywood-version of the Holocaust that is far removed from reality. The Twilight Zone-esquire twist ending is almost offensive. Information technology feels like an exploitation of existent life tragedies for the purpose of a cheap shock moment, and that'southward only tasteless.
Skillful performances by the child actors and Vera Farmiga couldn't save this moving picture. I'm surprised that information technology received such a high rating on IMDb, and I wait my review to exist deemed "not useful" by countless users soon. My judgement remains, though: "The Boy In The Stiped Pyjama" is an inappropriate fairy tale of horrific historic events that are still as well recent to exist distorted into a polished Hollywood tearjerker.
26 out of fifty constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Are you kidding me?
This movie is proof that we have reached the point of diminishing returns on films about the Holocaust. Many reviewers here have already recounted the ridiculous storyline, the bad acting, etc., and so I'll skip over that attribute of this cinematic failure. What struck me more than anything is how implausible the plot was and how unforgivably manipulative the ending is. My but emotions every bit the credits rolled on this dud were of disbelief that anyone would make such an irresponsible movie about such a serious subject thing. And so it brings me to the decision that we may just take said all there is to say almost the Holocaust. When movies like this begin to appear, it's subject, the Holocaust, has become a tool. A tool for money making, emotional exploitation, or commercialization. It is a disservice to history, and to the murdered millions, to use the Holocaust in such a shallow arbitrary manner. Don't meet this motion-picture show.
99 out of 204 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
I told you lot, it's not a game; nosotros just all have numbers
I oasis't read the novel, nor did I know of it. When I starting time heard of this, I knew I would watch it. I honestly did want to like this. Let's start with a complaint I've heard; the children exercise not talk similar adults. My guess is that whoever thinks they practise is affected by the fact that they speak British, not American, English; aye, some of it is upper class and such, notwithstanding, offspring of these people would exist using those words. As Ebert points out, it fits, it shows their level in society. I also want to say that the accurateness(the lack of German language notwithstanding), is impressive(other than the outspoken mother... non after '34). Before, I believed that the music early on was not the sort that would be heard in that location, but I asked my father who'southward an skilful on the subject, and he confirmed that information technology could and would. This tries to cram in a lot of information about the Nazis and their propaganda; I couldn't help discover how awkwardly shoe-horned in a lot of information technology was. The feminism is downright misplaced; there was still only a little support for equal rights for the genders in the residuum of the Western world around the 1940's. Almost of what this tells us is truthful, though; the issue is that the thing is non long plenty for it to come naturally. In general, this doesn't seem to realize that information technology'southward a mere 90 minutes, only the last twenty of which are all that engaging. I tin't claim that this actually captured me. The kids, for how well-behaved they can be, are annoying(y'all need to sell me on why I'm meant to care nearly these people, regardless of age). It's not their perspective that bothers me; I *love* Let The Right Ane In. The bonding footage is oddly placed late in this. Bruno isn't that appealing, both as a character and based on the actor. The performances are good. Editing and cinematography are overnice. The writing varies... is it just me, or are these people kinda stupid? Take the dinner scene, for case. There is cursory and intense agonizing content(and an underlying tone of it in other portions), and instant nudity in this. The DVD comes with an interesting commentary runway by the writer, author and director, a featurette that I will review on its own folio here on the site, and 6 minutes of deleted scenes with the pick of hearing the thoughts on them. I recommend this to those who want to catch every well-made movie about the Holocaust. seven/10
2 out of 2 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Moving + doesn't put a pes wrong
You don't oft sit down in a BAFTA screening and hear weeping behind you lot simply even the most hardened cineaste would be moved past this look at the holocaust through an Aryan child's eyes.
Information technology is beautifully scripted, acted and shot besides - with none of the anachronisms of taste and language that bedevil historically-set up films such as The Duchess.
A small, British moving-picture show with an unusual take on a ghastly and well-worn bailiwick.
PS - for parents: It's a 12A in Britain and I wouldn't accept a child nether almost xi. Nor would I allow them go alone.
79 out of 119 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Evil equally seen though the eyes of innocent children
wlb 23 Nov 2008
Of all my reviews, I believe that this is the first "9" I accept given a moving-picture show. I do not know the mechanics of the film business concern and distribution, but I had been hearing "buzz" and radio advertisements about this motion-picture show for the last 30 days, and it wasn't until recently that it opened in only 2 theaters (25 miles apart) in all of metropolitan Sacramento.
The motion-picture show affected me on several levels- ane of which how a nice "family man" could become an SS commandant over a concentration army camp. The father was happily married with an 8 year erstwhile boy and 12 twelvemonth old daughter.
And the family (wife and mother in law) had some conversations that I am sure resonated in at to the lowest degree a few German family unit households during that era.
The male parent justified his work with the rationalization heard over history with genocide that "they aren't really people".
I will have to say that given the usual mindless entertainment on the silver screen this movie will stay with you.
The main theme of the moving-picture show is how 2 innocent viii yr quondam boys are afflicted past evil, and man's inhumanity to man.
I had heard some detractors say that all of the "Germans" are speaking with English language accents, including the American actress Vera Farmiga (I suppose to stay consistent with the other British actors) - their contention that somehow this detracts from the authenticity.
The interim and the script takes you to wartime Germany, with whatever accents the actors are using. That is the best compliment that I can give.
One of the twelvemonth'due south best, in my opinion.
17 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Amateurish Revisionist Garbage
Warning: Spoilers
An earlier poster has described this as 'the holocaust for dummies', and it certainly is. I'm non going to step into the mire of factual accuracy, simply state that non one aspect of it presented the to the lowest degree appearance of realism.
In a nutshell; I didn't believe what I was watching. Maybe I've read too many accounts near the holocaust, just I don't recollect so. The whole production had an non-expert appearance, equally if based entirely upon 3rd-hand heresay rather than enquiry. The SS officers looked and behaved like caricatures. Gear up construction seemed minimalist. The interim was stiff and formulaic, script was crass. Fabricated on a express budget ($12m) was practically advertised in every accept. As to predictability - yous could encounter what was coming every bit soon every bit both boys confronted each other at the wire. Photographic camera-piece of work was unimaginative, editing clumsy and lacking any dramatic effect.
Here was a revisionist opportunity to requite at least 1 Nazi a sense of taste of his ain Zyklon. Come across how he feels about having his kid gassed. Yeah - right on, man.
Without doubt, the worst movie of the genre I have ever watched.
38 out of 85 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
We're not supposed to exist friends, yous and me. We're meant to be enemies. Did y'all know that?
The Male child in the Striped Pyjamas is directed by Mark Herman who also adapts the screenplay from the novel written past John Boyne. It stars David Thewlis, Vera Farmiga, Asa Butterfield and Jack Scanlon. Music is past James Horner and cinematography by Benoît Delhomme.
When his family is moved out to the state considering his commandant male parent is transferred, eight twelvemonth onetime Bruno (Butterfield) finds himself isolated, bewildered and bored. Forbidden to venture out beyond the rear of the house, Bruno finally has enough and happens upon what he thinks is a farm. Here he meets a strange boy sitting backside the barbed wire argue, wearing pyjamas. A friendship is born, merely at what cost?
The Holocaust always has, and e'er volition be tricky fabric for film makers to bring to the screen. Is it a form of exploitation? Emotional manipulation to grab your greenbacks? Or should films be out there about information technology to brainwash and ensure nobody forgets the horrors perpetrated during that sad time in history? What we exercise know is that there is no unified answer to be plant, it'south a touchy subject either style, simply in one case in a while there is a Holocaust based flick that begs to exist seen and appreciated past the film loving populace. Or mainly in this example, as a family viewing.
I oasis't read John Boyne's novel, I now wish I had. The Male child in the Striped Pyjamas comes at united states through the eyes of a child, it's a unlike approach that works beautifully. The innocence to the horrors being committed out yonder of young Bruno's back yard, hits home like a bolt from the blue. This innocence is reciprocated by the immature male child, Shmuel (Scanlon), sitting on the other side of the contend, their innocence, puzzlement and yearning for harmonised exploration is a bastion of what is bully in the world. There is no distinguishment between race, creed or colour, they just see another young boy looking dorsum at them through the barbed wire. And crucially the dialogue given them is unfettered, fresh, pure, unproblematic and believable in its youthfulness.
Elsewhere, Bruno's parents are advisedly written and performed. Thewlis' father character, the commandant of the campsite, is overseer of crimes that still send hate ripples through the world today, but we see him equally a man, a loving begetter, in that location's juxtaposition nagging away at the viewer. Farmiga's mother, perhaps guilty of naivety? Yet she's very torn between loyalty to husband and the family unit life and condemnation of expiry campsite atrocities. The Grandma (Sheila Hancock), also, is not shy in coming forward to oppose such vile "politics", these are strong narrative spurts, do not tar with the same brush springs to mind. The tutorial education (attempted corruption) of youth factor is played, deftly, while nationalist propaganda via Theresienstadt similar video film ensures history has been taken notice of.
Invariably there are distressing scenes and passages of dialogue, simply since the story is shot through a boy's world view, nosotros don't need to see up shut an assault or take the obvious hit united states of america over the head. The off camera sound of a kicking connecting with flesh, the hushed vocalism of a Jewish servant telling of a life he once lived, or a shot of smoke from furnace chimneys, it'due south all we demand to feel sadness and disgust until the finale, where although Herman is careful and astute, he shocks the senses, and then closes with a silent pull away shot that cuts similar a knife as nosotros reverberate on the story just unfolded before the states. Emotional manipulation? Non a chip of it. A brilliant and worthy picture show, one that parents should seriously consider watching with their kids. 9/10
five out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Source: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0914798/reviews
0 Response to "The Boy in the Striped Pajamas Plugged in Movie Review"
Post a Comment